Hair Fall Shampoo products are flooding the market, but how do you choose the right one for your hair type and scalp condition? I faced the same dilemma and decided to test two well-known shampoos: Mamaearth Onion Hair Fall Shampoo and Biotique Bio Kelp Protein Shampoo. Over a 8-week period, I used each shampoo for Four weeks, tracking every change—both good and bad.
Below is my detailed comparison based on real usage, product formulation, fragrance, texture, packaging, and overall performance. If you’re struggling with hair fall and unsure which shampoo to trust, this review will help you make the right choice.
Table of Contents
Product Overview
Mamaearth Onion Hair Fall Shampoo
Mamaearth Onion Hair Fall Shampoo is a gentle, sulfate-free formula designed to reduce hair fall and promote hair growth naturally. Enriched with Onion Extract, Plant Keratin, and Vitamin E, it strengthens hair strands, minimizes breakage, and nourishes the scalp. Ideal for all hair types, including chemically treated and colored hair, this shampoo provides deep cleansing without stripping natural oils. It’s dermatologically tested, free from harmful chemicals, and safe for regular use to support healthier, shinier hair.
Key Ingredients Breakdown
- Onion Extract: Promotes hair growth and reduces breakage
- Plant Keratin: Strengthens hair structure
- D-Panthenol & Vitamin E: Adds moisture and shine
Biotique Bio Kelp Protein Shampoo
Biotique Bio Kelp Protein Shampoo is an herbal Ayurvedic solution formulated to strengthen hair and combat hair fall. Enriched with nutrient-rich kelp, rejuvenating bhringraj, purifying neem, and invigorating peppermint, this shampoo nourishes the scalp while promoting hair growth. Its gel-like consistency lathers well and deeply cleanses without harsh sulfates or parabens. Ideal for oily to normal hair types, it helps clear buildup, reduce itchiness, and enhance natural shine.
Key Ingredients Breakdown
- Kelp: A seaweed rich in iodine, helps nourish hair roots
- Bhringraj: Known in Ayurveda for promoting hair regrowth
- Neem & Peppermint Oil: Cleanse and purify the scalp
Features | Mamaearth Onion Hair Fall Shampoo | Biotique Bio Kelp Protein Shampoo |
|---|---|---|
Preview |  |  |
Brand | Mamaearth | Biotique |
Hair Type | All | Oily scalps |
Item Form | Liquid | Lotion |
Product Benefits | Strengthening, Anti-Hair Loss, Smoothening | Anti-Hair Loss, Hair Growth |
Liquid Volume | 1 Litres | 500 Millilitres |
Buy Now |
Packaging and First Impressions
Mamaearth Onion Hair Fall Shampoo: The pump-style bottle feels premium and easy to use, especially during a busy shower routine. The packaging is sturdy, hygienic, and travel-safe. The scent is a subtle blend of onion and herbs—noticeable but not overpowering.
Biotique Bio Kelp Protein Shampoo: This shampoo comes in a tall bottle with a flip-cap. It’s lightweight, compact, and great for travel. The fragrance is more intense—a strong herbal note that lingers post-wash.
User Experience: I personally liked Mamaearth’s pump design more. It’s convenient and reduces wastage. However, Biotique’s compact bottle is ideal for short trips and gym bags. In terms of fragrance, those sensitive to strong herbal smells may prefer Mamaearth.
Texture and Application
Mamaearth: Creamy and smooth texture. Spreads easily over wet hair and needs a moderate amount to cover the scalp and strands. Lathers decently and washes out without leaving any residue.
Biotique: Blue gel-like formula. A little goes a long way—it lathers strongly, especially on oily hair. However, I noticed a slight dryness in the ends after every wash.
User Experience: Mamaearth felt gentler on my strands. After use, my hair felt softer and tangle-free. Biotique delivered a deep-cleaning effect, which is great for oily scalps but required a follow-up with conditioner to prevent dryness.
Real-Life Usage Experience
Using Mamaearth: From the first use, Mamaearth Onion Hair Fall Shampoo felt mild and suitable for daily use. After a few washes, I noticed my scalp remained clean for longer, and hair fall during combing had reduced. My hair started to feel softer, smoother, and more manageable. The presence of keratin and Vitamin E added a light shine, and with regular use, there was a visible 30–35% reduction in hair fall. It did not irritate my scalp and worked well even on colored hair.
Using Biotique: Biotique Bio Kelp Protein Shampoo made an instant impact with its deep-cleansing effect. It was especially effective on my oily scalp, making it feel refreshed and less greasy for days. I experienced a significant improvement in scalp health—fewer flakes, reduced itching, and a feeling of cleanliness. Hair fall reduced steadily by around 40% over consistent use. However, it left my hair a bit dry at the ends, so I always followed up with a conditioner.
User Verdict: While Mamaearth showed better results in terms of texture and softness, Biotique worked great for scalp detox and deep cleansing. Both shampoos controlled hair fall effectively, but in slightly different ways. Mamaearth targeted the hair strands and breakage, while Biotique strengthened roots and improved scalp condition.
Pros and Cons
Mamaearth Onion Hair Fall Shampoo
Biotique Bio Kelp Protein Shampoo
Who Should Use Which?
Choose Mamaearth if:
- You have frizzy or chemically treated hair
- You prefer mild, dermatologically safe formulations
- You’re okay with a slightly higher price for long-term benefits
Choose Biotique if:
- You struggle with an oily, itchy scalp
- You want Ayurvedic ingredients at a budget price
- You don’t mind using conditioner to manage dryness
Final Verdict
After 8 weeks of testing, here’s my honest summary:
- Mamaearth Onion Hair Fall Shampoo stands out for its gentle yet effective formulation. It gradually improves hair health and is ideal for regular use.
- Biotique Bio Kelp Protein Shampoo is a powerful herbal cleanser. It’s effective for scalp detox but may need pairing with conditioner.
If I had to choose one for daily use, I’d pick Mamaearth. But if I needed a deep cleanse or scalp refresh once a week, I’d reach for Biotique.
My Honest Rating
- Mamaearth: (4.4 Out of 5)
- Biotique: (4.0 Out of 5)
When choosing a Hair Fall Shampoo, it’s important to consider your hair type, scalp condition, and routine. Both Mamaearth Onion Hair Fall Shampoo and Biotique Bio Kelp Protein Shampoo have their own strengths. Whether you want a gentle formula for everyday use or an Ayurvedic cleanser for a weekly detox, both options deliver solid results.
Try both, observe how your hair responds, and stay consistent. And don’t forget—good hair health starts with a healthy lifestyle too!
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Q1: Is biotique hair fall shampoo harmful?
Not inherently harmful for most, but some users report dryness, irritation, and even increased hair fall—especially without conditioner.
Q2: How to prevent hair fall?
Maintain a healthy diet, avoid heat styling, use gentle hair care products, manage stress, and massage scalp regularly to prevent hair fall.
Q3: Is Mamaearth onion hair fall shampoo good?
Mamaearth Onion Hair Fall Shampoo is gentle, sulfate‑free, and can reduce breakage for some, but others report dryness, scalp irritation, or worsened hair fall
