Hair fall shampoos are some of the most widely searched products in the world of hair care. With stress, pollution, and lifestyle changes becoming everyday concerns, finding the right hair fall solution is more important than ever. Two popular contenders in the Indian market are the Mamaearth Onion Hair Fall Shampoo and the TRESemmé Hair Fall Defense Shampoo. In this article, I will walk you through my honest comparison based on few weeks of personal usage. From packaging to performance, you’ll get a complete overview of these two leading hair fall shampoos.
Table of Contents
Product Overview
Mamaearth Onion Hair Fall Shampoo
Mamaearth Onion Hair Fall Shampoo is a gentle, sulfate-free formula designed to strengthen and nourish hair while reducing hair fall. Formulated with onion extract, plant keratin, and vitamin E, it repairs damaged strands, enhances shine, and supports scalp health. Ideal for all hair types—including chemically treated or colored hair—it cleanses without stripping natural oils. Dermatologically tested and free from harmful chemicals like parabens, silicones, and mineral oils, this shampoo offers effective hair fall control with each wash.
Key Ingredients Breakdown
- Onion Oil: Strengthens hair roots
- Plant Keratin: Improves hair texture
- Vitamin E: Nourishes the scalp
- Free from sulfates, parabens, and silicones
TRESemmé Hair Fall Defense Shampoo
TRESemmé Hair Fall Defense Shampoo is a salon-grade formula designed to strengthen hair and minimize breakage. Enriched with keratin protein, it reinforces strands from root to tip, helping prevent hair fall caused by brushing or styling. The creamy, sulfate-infused lather cleanses thoroughly and delivers a smooth, shiny finish. Suitable for daily use, it’s particularly effective for chemically treated or heat-styled hair. With its vibrant fragrance and widely available packaging, it offers a premium yet accessible solution for hair strengthening.
Key Ingredients Breakdown
- Keratin Protein: Strengthens and smoothens hair
- Contains sulfates and silicones for cleansing and conditioning
- Not fully natural or free from chemicals
Features | Mamaearth Onion Hair Fall Shampoo | TRESemmé Hair Fall Defense Shampoo |
|---|---|---|
Preview |  |  |
Brand | Mamaearth | TRESemme |
Hair Type | All | All |
Item Form | Liquid | Cream |
Product Benefits | Strengthening, Anti-Hair Loss, Smoothening | hair strength, prevents hair fall |
Liquid Volume | 1 Litres | 1 Litres |
Buy Now |
Packaging & First Impressions
Mamaearth: Comes in a sturdy white bottle with a pump dispenser. It feels more premium and is user-friendly. The labeling is clean, highlighting the key natural ingredients and chemical-free promise. It immediately gives off a clean, safe, Ayurvedic vibe.
TRESemmé: Offers its classic sleek black bottle with a flip-top cap. It looks professional and salon-grade. The branding is bold, promising hair fall defense with keratin protein. While not natural-looking, it appeals to users seeking science-backed formulations.
Verdict: Mamaearth wins in convenience and clean branding. TRESemmé wins in salon-like feel.
Texture and Fragrance
Mamaearth: The shampoo has a runny consistency with a light onion and herbal scent. The fragrance is mild and doesn’t linger after wash. It lathers decently for a sulfate-free shampoo.
TRESemmé: Creamier and richer texture, with a pleasant, perfumed fragrance that lasts longer. Lathers very well due to sulfates.
Verdict: If you prefer natural and light, go with Mamaearth. If you enjoy a luxurious feel and strong fragrance, TRESemmé stands out.
Scalp and Hair Feel Post-Wash
Mamaearth: Leaves the scalp feeling fresh, non-greasy, and light. Hair may feel a bit dry if not followed by a conditioner. Suitable for oily scalps.
TRESemmé: Hair feels soft, smooth, and frizz-free post-wash. Scalp remains clean but may not suit very oily or sensitive scalps due to sulfates.
Verdict: Mamaearth works better for those with sensitive or oily scalps. TRESemmé is perfect for dry, frizzy hair.
Real-World Usage Insights
Instead of reviewing results week-by-week, let’s look at how both hair fall shampoos performed in real-life conditions under regular use—3 to 4 washes per week, over one month.
Mamaearth: What stood out was the gradual but steady improvement in hair strength and reduced hair fall. Initially, the dryness at the ends required a conditioner, but by the third week, my hair looked fuller. I noticed fewer strands on my pillow and while combing. The appearance of baby hairs was a positive sign, suggesting potential regrowth. The formula felt gentle on my scalp, and I experienced no irritation or itchiness throughout the trial.
TRESemmé: This shampoo delivered immediate softness and smoothness right from the first wash. It helped reduce breakage during brushing and detangling. However, deeper concerns like hair thinning and root strength showed no major improvement. It worked great as a surface-level fix but didn’t seem to promote long-term hair health. Users with dry, frizzy hair may love the instant texture boost, but results plateaued after the second week.
Verdict: Mamaearth offers lasting changes when used consistently. TRESemmé is perfect for quick results in appearance, but not in root-level recovery.
Price & Value for Money
Mamaearth: Priced slightly higher, but offers a clean formula and long-term benefits. A 250ml bottle lasts around 4-5 weeks.
TRESemmé: Budget-friendly and easily available. A little goes a long way. The 340ml bottle is good for 6 weeks.
Verdict: TRESemmé is better for budget buyers. Mamaearth is ideal for those investing in clean beauty.
Pros and Cons
Mamaearth Onion Hair Fall Shampoo
TRESemmé Hair Fall Defense Shampoo
Who Should Use Which?
Use Mamaearth if:
- You have an oily or sensitive scalp
- You want natural and chemical-free products
- You’re looking for long-term reduction in hair fall
Use TRESemmé if:
- You want instant smoothness and salon-like feel
- You have dry or frizzy hair
- You prefer stronger fragrance and rich lather
Final Verdict: Which Hair Fall Shampoo Wins?
Both hair fall shampoos have their strengths and limitations. Mamaearth Onion Hair Fall Shampoo worked better for me in reducing actual hair fall and improving scalp health over four weeks. It felt safer and more suitable for long-term use, especially with visible regrowth. On the other hand, TRESemmé Hair Fall Defense Shampoo offered instant shine, smoothness, and a great fragrance but lacked in long-term hair fall control.
If you’re looking for visible hair fall reduction with minimal chemicals, go for Mamaearth. If you want shine, softness, and better styling experience, try TRESemmé. Choose based on your scalp type and long-term hair goals.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Q1: Does TRESemmé hair fall shampoos actually stop hair fall?
TRESemmé Hair Fall Shampoos may help reduce hair fall caused by breakage. However, its effectiveness varies among users.
Q2: What are the side effects of Mamaearth onion hair fall shampoos?
While Mamaearth Onion Hair Fall Shampoos is generally safe for most users, some individuals may experience side effects such as scalp irritation, dryness, or dandruff.
Q3: Can I use Mamaearth Onion Shampoo without conditioner?
While it’s possible to use Mamaearth Onion Shampoo without a conditioner, it’s generally not recommended for optimal hair health. The shampoo is free from sulfates, parabens, and silicones, making it gentle and suitable for daily use.
