Introduction – A Story of Two Choices
Ananya, a 29-year-old marketing professional, had been battling severe hair fall for months. Stress at work, pollution, and long commutes in the city made it worse. Every morning, she noticed strands of hair on her pillow and comb, which only added to her anxiety. One weekend, determined to fix her hair woes, she stood at a pharmacy aisle debating between two popular choices: the Pilgrim Advanced Hair Growth Serum and the Mamaearth Onion Scalp Serum. Both claimed to reduce hair fall and promote growth, but which one would truly deliver results?
If you’re also one of the many readers who want to know Pilgrim Advanced Hair Growth Serum vs Mamaearth Onion Scalp Serum: Which is Better to Reduce Hair Fall, you’re in the right place. According to a report by Fortune Business Insights (2023), the global hair care market is projected to grow from USD 91.2 billion in 2022 to USD 147.4 billion by 2030, with serums gaining traction as effective hair treatments. But when it comes to choosing between these two bestsellers, the decision requires more than just reading the label.
At Shopwithchoice, we break down the pros and cons of popular products with detailed overviews, key features, customer feedback, and side-by-side comparisons so you can make informed decisions for your hair health.
1) Pilgrim Advanced Hair Growth Serum: An Overview
The Pilgrim Advanced Hair Growth Serum is formulated with ingredients inspired by Korean beauty science. It focuses on reducing hair fall, stimulating follicles, and improving scalp health through active ingredients like Redensyl, Anagain, and Baicapil.
🔗Check Price on Amazon
Price Range in India: ₹1,046 – ₹1,246
Key Features:
- Enriched with 3 powerful actives: Redensyl, Anagain, Baicapil.
- Designed to target the hair follicle growth cycle.
- Lightweight, non-sticky, and easy to apply.
- Dermatologically tested and safe for all hair types.
- Free from sulfates, parabens, and harmful chemicals.
Pros:
- Scientifically backed ingredients with proven results in clinical studies.
- Reduces hair fall while promoting thicker, denser hair.
- Suitable for both men and women.
- Non-greasy formula makes it ideal for daily use.
Cons:
- Visible results may take 8–12 weeks.
- Slightly more complex formula than natural alternatives, which may not appeal to minimalists.
Real Customer Experiences:
👉“I don’t usually write such long reviews, but for this I have to because it’s so good. I have been using this serum for the past few days, and since it’s water-based, it doesn’t feel greasy at all. I use it every night, and the best thing is that you don’t have to wash it off after every application. I will definitely buy this again. For now, I can see a reduction in hair fall, but for noticeable hair growth results, I need to use it for a few more weeks.”
👉“I’ve been using the Pilgrim Advanced Hair Growth Serum 3% + Anagain 4% for a few weeks, and I’ve already noticed a difference in the thickness and strength of my hair. The serum is lightweight and non-greasy, making it easy to apply without weighing my hair down. A must-try!”
2) Mamaearth Onion Scalp Serum: An Overview
The Mamaearth Onion Scalp Serum leverages the natural benefits of onion extracts, known for strengthening roots and reducing hair thinning. It’s a product marketed heavily for natural, toxin-free care.
🔗Check Price on Amazon
Price Range in India: ₹420 – ₹620
Key Features:
- Infused with onion seed extract for reducing breakage.
- Enriched with niacinamide and biotin for scalp nourishment.
- Designed for daily scalp application without greasiness.
- Made with natural, toxin-free ingredients.
- Dermatologically tested, suitable for all hair types.
Pros:
- Natural and toxin-free formulation.
- Affordable and widely available.
- Helps improve scalp health and reduces breakage.
- Easy to integrate into daily routine.
Cons:
- Onion smell may not appeal to everyone.
- Results are often slower compared to advanced actives.
- Works better for mild hair fall than severe cases.
Real Customer Experiences:
👉“It is an amazing product, I really like it. It dissolves into the scalp so quickly and has no bad smell. I use it at night, and in the morning, I feel like I didn’t apply anything. It is so good, and after only two uses, I feel my hair fall has almost stopped. Thank you, Mamaearth, for this amazing product.”
👉“I love this product! It worked amazingly on my hair, and I love the scent. The smell is not like a typical oil; it’s very soothing, and my hair feels softer after using it for just 2 days. Highly recommended!”
Top 5 Best Hair Serums for Men in 2025
Pilgrim Advanced Hair Growth Serum vs Mamaearth Onion Scalp Serum – Comparison Table
Feature | Pilgrim Advanced Hair Growth Serum | Mamaearth Onion Scalp Serum |
|---|---|---|
Image | | |
Key Ingredients | Redensyl, Anagain, Baicapil | Onion extract, Niacinamide, Biotin |
Formula Type | Advanced scientific actives | Natural and toxin-free |
Texture | Lightweight, non-sticky | Light, with mild onion fragrance |
Best For | Moderate to severe hair fall | Mild to moderate hair fall |
Results Timeline | 8–12 weeks for visible results | Gradual results, may take longer |
Customer Feedback | Praised for density and regrowth | Praised for scalp health, affordability |
Drawbacks | Patience required for results | Onion smell, slower effects |
Ratings | 4 out of 5 | 3.9 out of 5 |
Price |
Buying Tips – How to Choose the Best Hair Serum
- Check Ingredients: If you prefer scientifically backed actives, Pilgrim is a better choice; for natural options, go with Mamaearth.
- Severity of Hair Fall: For severe issues, choose Pilgrim; for mild thinning, Mamaearth may be sufficient.
- Scalp Sensitivity: Sensitive scalps may respond better to natural formulations.
- Lifestyle Needs: If you need quick absorption with no residue, Pilgrim works better.
Usage Tips – How to Use Hair Serum Properly
- Clean Scalp First: Apply only to clean, dry scalp for best absorption.
- Consistency is Key: Use daily or as directed, since results take weeks.
- Massage Gently: Massage serum into the scalp to improve circulation.
- Don’t Overapply: A few drops are enough — excess serum won’t accelerate results.
- Track Progress: Take photos every 4 weeks to monitor improvement.
5 Best Hair Serums to Prevent Hair Fall and Promote Hair Growth for Women
FAQs – Pilgrim Advanced Hair Growth Serum vs Mamaearth Onion Scalp Serum
Q1: Which is better for severe hair fall?
👉Pilgrim Advanced Hair Growth Serum with Redensyl and Anagain is better suited.
Q2: Which is more natural?
👉Mamaearth Onion Scalp Serum uses natural onion extracts and biotin.
Q3: Do they cause side effects?
👉Both are dermatologically tested; however, patch testing is recommended.
Q4: How long until I see results?
👉Pilgrim may show results in 8–12 weeks, while Mamaearth takes longer depending on hair condition.
Q5: Can they be used by both men and women?
👉Yes, both serums are unisex.
Conclusion:
So, which one should you choose?
- If you’re dealing with moderate to severe hair fall and want scientifically proven actives, go with Pilgrim Advanced Hair Growth Serum.
- If you prefer a natural, toxin-free, and budget-friendly option for mild hair fall, Mamaearth Onion Scalp Serum is a good choice.
- If non-sticky texture and faster absorption matter most, Pilgrim is your best bet.
- If you want to stick with natural remedies and don’t mind waiting longer, Mamaearth works well.
Both serums have their strengths, but it ultimately depends on your hair type, lifestyle, and expectations. so, which one will you trust to bring back your healthy, strong hair?
