Shampoo plays a vital role in maintaining healthy hair, especially when combating hair fall. With countless options available, finding a product that truly delivers can be challenging. In this battle-tested review, I share my personal experience comparing two popular hair fall shampoos: Mamaearth Onion Hair Fall Shampoo and Clinic Plus Strong & Long Health Shampoo. Both claim to reduce hair fall and strengthen hair, but how do they perform in real life? Join me as I reveal honest insights, pros and cons, and which shampoo stood out during my personal hair care journey.
Table of Contents
Understanding the Shampoo Basics
Choosing the right shampoo isn’t just about fragrance or packaging—it’s about how well it suits your scalp, hair type, and addresses specific concerns like hair fall or dandruff. Hair fall can be triggered by many factors including hormonal imbalances, pollution, stress, or harsh hair care products. Therefore, the shampoo you select plays a pivotal role in maintaining scalp health, preventing breakage, and supporting new hair growth.
Product Overview
Mamaearth Onion Hair Fall Shampoo
Mamaearth Onion Hair Fall Shampoo is a plant-based formula designed to reduce hair fall and promote stronger hair growth. Enriched with natural ingredients like onion oil, plant keratin, and vitamin E, this shampoo gently cleanses the scalp while strengthening roots. It is free from sulfates, parabens, silicones, and dyes, making it suitable for all hair types, including color-treated hair. The gentle formula helps improve scalp health and supports long-term hair resilience.
Ingredient Analysis & Scalp Impact
Mamaearth’s formula highlights key natural components:
- Onion Oil: Rich in sulfur and antioxidants, it promotes stronger hair follicles and reduces hair thinning.
- Plant Keratin: Helps repair damaged hair and adds resilience.
- Vitamin E: Nourishes the scalp and supports hair health.
- Free from harsh chemicals: No sulfates, parabens, silicones, making it ideal for sensitive scalps and color-treated hair.
Clinic Plus Strong & Long Health Shampoo
Clinic Plus Strong & Long Health Shampoo is a classic, affordable option known for its rich, creamy lather and family-friendly appeal. Infused with milk protein and essential minerals, it strengthens hair strands from root to tip, reducing breakage and enhancing manageability. The creamy texture comfortably coats each strand, offering softness without needing conditioner for most users. While containing sulfates and parabens, its nourishing formula and pleasant floral scent make it a reliable, budget-conscious choice for everyday hair care.
Ingredient Analysis & Scalp Impact
Clinic Plus includes:
- Milk Protein: Provides nourishment and strengthens hair shafts.
- Minerals: Help maintain scalp balance.
- Contains sulfates and parabens which can be harsh with prolonged use, especially on sensitive scalps.
Features | Mamaearth Onion Hair Fall Shampoo | Clinic Plus Strong & Long Health Shampoo |
|---|---|---|
Preview |  |  |
Brand | Mamaearth | Clinic Plus |
Hair Type | All | All |
Item Form | Liquid | Liquid |
Product Benefits | Strengthening, Anti-Hair Loss, Smoothening | Nourishing |
Liquid Volume | 1 Litres | 1 Litres |
Buy Now |
Packaging & Usability
Mamaearth presents its shampoo in a sturdy, minimalistic white bottle with a pump dispenser. This design is not only visually appealing but also functional, allowing controlled dispensing which reduces wastage—a smart choice for those concerned about sustainability.
Clinic Plus retains its classic, vibrant blue packaging with a flip-top cap, instantly recognizable and easy to handle even in wet conditions. It reflects a no-nonsense, value-for-money product aimed at mass consumers.
In terms of user experience, the pump on Mamaearth is smooth and convenient, especially for daily users, whereas Clinic Plus’s flip cap is simple but effective.
Texture, Scent and Initial Feel
Mamaearth’s shampoo has a semi-transparent, slightly viscous texture. Its fragrance is mild, dominated by herbal notes with a faint onion scent which surprisingly isn’t overpowering or unpleasant. This subtlety is a relief for those sensitive to strong scents or chemical perfumes.
Clinic Plus, contrastingly, has a thick creamy texture with a strong floral fragrance. The scent lingers in the hair longer, which many users find refreshing, but it may feel artificial or heavy for some.
While washing, Mamaearth produces moderate lather and feels gentle on the scalp. Clinic Plus foams richly and feels like a thorough cleanser, which can be more satisfying for those used to foamy shampoos.
Effectiveness in Controlling Hair Fall
Hair fall is the ultimate test for these shampoos.
Using Mamaearth consistently, I noticed a gradual but definitive reduction in hair shedding, especially during combing and after washing. My scalp felt invigorated, less itchy, and over time, hair strands appeared thicker. The natural ingredients seemed to strengthen the hair roots, supporting new growth.
Clinic Plus delivered a different experience. Initially, hair felt stronger and shinier, but the shampoo did not significantly reduce hair fall. The protein content helped with the texture and softness but didn’t target the root cause of hair loss. It worked better as a daily cleanser rather than a treatment for hair fall.
Managing Hair Texture and Moisture
Mamaearth’s shampoo can leave hair ends slightly dry if used alone, so pairing it with a hydrating conditioner is important to maintain softness and manageability. It’s more suited for those with oily or combination scalps looking to strengthen hair over time.
Clinic Plus’s creamy formula often made my hair feel smoother and easier to detangle immediately after washing, even without conditioner. This instant softness is a major plus for those seeking quick, hassle-free grooming.
Price Point & Availability
Mamaearth Onion Hair Fall Shampoo is positioned in the mid-to-premium range and is primarily available online. Despite being costlier, it appeals to users seeking chemical-free, natural solutions and is often offered with discounts and subscription options.
Clinic Plus is one of the most affordable shampoos available in almost every local store and online, making it accessible to a wide demographic. Its budget-friendly pricing is a key factor for families and daily users.
Pros and Cons
Mamaearth Onion Hair Fall Shampoo
Clinic Plus Strong & Long Health Shampoo
Who Should Choose Which Shampoo?
Opt for Mamaearth Onion Shampoo if:
- You want a natural, chemical-free hair fall solution
- You have a sensitive or oily scalp
- You are willing to invest for long-term hair health
Choose Clinic Plus Strong & Long Shampoo if:
- You prefer an affordable, easily accessible shampoo
- You want quick softness and manageable hair
- Hair fall is not a severe issue but you want general strengthening
My Final Thoughts and Recommendations
After rigorously testing both shampoos, my verdict leans strongly towards Mamaearth Onion Hair Fall Shampoo for those serious about reducing hair fall and improving scalp health naturally. Its clean ingredient profile and gradual effectiveness make it a worthwhile investment.
Meanwhile, Clinic Plus Strong & Long Health Shampoo remains a reliable daily shampoo for softness and shine, especially if budget constraints are a concern or if you prefer a traditional formula.
Ultimately, choosing between these shampoos depends on your priorities: natural care and hair fall control versus affordability and immediate hair softness.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Q1: Can I use Clinic Plus Shampoo daily?
Yes, you can use Clinic Plus Shampoo daily, but it may dry out hair over time due to sulfates.
Q2: Can Clinic Plus stop hair fall?
Clinic Plus may reduce breakage with regular use, but it doesn’t effectively stop hair fall caused by deeper scalp or hormonal issues.
Q3: Is Mamaearth safe or not?
Mamaearth Onion Hair Fall Shampoo is generally safe, but some users report scalp irritation, dryness, dandruff, or increased hair fall—especially without conditioner.
